Are We Consuming Too Much?
There is an easy answer to that question, which is the title of an arcane bit of academic writing done by a Nobel Laureate Economist, Kenneth Arrow. I spent a couple of weeks reading and recapitulating his piece as an independent study project in my undergraduate work.
The question he was really attempting to answer: By how much are we over consuming? Which is a critical bit of knowledge that's still outside of our knowing.
We are, by Nature, Consumptive Beasts, we must consume to prolong our existence.
Is this necessarily a bad thing?
Should we carry guilt over this?
Or is the attraction to shiny new bits of consumerism more the culprit? Certainly we could use a bit Maslow, and a little teeny tiny bit of Puritan ethic to differentiate the two. Does our need for shelter include a McMansion? Does the extra weight I carry constitute overeating? Does my 30 year old (think high use for the embodied energy) high milage Volkswagen, which runs biodiesel (think short supply chain, low emission in production, and only 20% less tailpipe emissions than regular gas) justify my using it to go to the gym? Shouldn't I just ride my bike? Or my current model, not so fuel efficient motorcycle? Should I be using guilt as a motvator, or use some common sense?
What is the scale of change we need to survive as a species? What behaviors return me to sanity and happiness? My internal sense of well being is a key driver to my ability to make change in the world.
How do we make sense of our choices?
How do you?
Stephen, these are great questions and I think its hard to figure out the answers. Knowing how much to consume varies person to person and it should be something that people are awakening to the realization of needing to consume less.
ReplyDeleteThat said, it's hard, as you showed with your example of transportation, with so many options available to us to know if we are making the least worst decision for ourselves and the environment. Its almost as if we need to have less products and services available to us, so that we can get to the basics. But is this possible? And how do we motivate people to consume less?
So hard! We are surrounded on all sides by stuff, stuff, stuff! I always think of a Tom Robbins quote from Fierce Invalids Home From Hot Climates: "the more advertising I see, the less I want to buy".
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure how else to mediate my choices than awareness, and presence. I keep being stuck by the notion of information paralysis, the way that decision making suffers when there are too many options, too much information. So many of the tradeoffs that we make everyday are made with too much or too little information.
I know that I consume too much, and that I struggle daily with my decisions to do so. For me, I have to work on my internal space, on my decision making processes, and take the world one small decision at a time.